Should all working Santas get the H1N1 shot?
"Absolutely," he said.
Winters said his doctor suggested that he
get the shot, even calling him a "critical
case."
"He asked me how many kids I'll see this
year. I said thousands, and he immediately
said I was a top priority for the shot," he
said.
In fact, Winters said his doctor told him
that he would have called him anyway for the
shot.
"I don't want to catch anything, but God
forbid I gave [the flu] to the children," he
said.
How vulnerable is Santa?
Although Winters got the vaccine, recent
news reports have suggested that getting the
shot has proven to be more difficult for
Santas in some states.
That's because the vaccine is in limited
supply and Santas are not officially in the
priority high-risk group as defined by the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
(CDC).
The CDC recommends that the H1N1 vaccine be
first given to pregnant women, people who
live with or care for children younger than
6 months of age, healthcare and emergency
medical services personnel, people between
the ages of 6 months and 24 years old, and
people ages 25 through 64 years of age who
are at a higher risk because of chronic
health disorders or compromised immune
systems.
"We understand that workers who are in close
contact with children, (Santas, teachers,
etc.) may be concerned about getting
infected with the H1N1 virus, and thus would
like to be considered in the priority groups
for vaccination," Arleen Porcell-Pharr,
public affairs specialist with the CDC wrote
in an e-mail.
"However, our recommendations on who should
first get vaccinated are based on scientific
evidence on who is being most affected by
the disease," she said.
At the same time, Porcell-Pharr told
CNNMoney.com that the CDC's guidelines are
recommendations.
"Santas can still go to their doctors and
say that they want the vaccination," she
said. "It's ideal if they can get it."
Swine flu is a big topic at the Charles W.
Howard Santa Claus School in Midland, Mich.,
where 70 Santas were trained for this year's
holiday season.
The school, which dates back to 1937 and
considers itself the "oldest school
dedicated to the art of portraying Santa
Claus," has a total base of about 500 Santas
who work in 35 states.
Holly Valent, the registrar, said the school
had two doctors come in to discuss
precautions regarding the swine flu.
"One doctor told the class they should get
the vaccination, but the other doctor said
they don't need it," said Valent.
She said some of the school's Santas have
gotten the H1N1 shot while others have not.
She did not provide specific numbers.
How many kids will Santa come into contact
with this year? Valent said the Santa Claus
School itself will see about 30,000 kids
from Dec. 1 to Dec. 23.
"At malls, it's hundreds of kids in an
eight-hour period a day," she said, adding
that the number jumps to more than a
thousand a day closer to Christmas.
Still, Valent said the school can only
suggest to working Santas to get the shot.
"We can't force them to get it."
'Best practices' against the flu
A organization called the Amalgamated Order
of Real Bearded Santas, which has more than
700 members, maintains that its members have
been able to get the H1N1 vaccine despite
not being in the priority group for it.
The group's president, Nicholas Trolli, said
when its members go to the doctor's office,
they check the box that asks if they are
working with a child under 6 months of age.
"They get priority for the vaccination the
same way a daycare worker does," Trolli
said.
Tim Connaghan, 62, a working Santa for 40
years, also runs a training school every
year for hundreds of Santas. Connaghan said
he has not heard from his students that they
are having problems getting the H1N1 vaccine
other than if it is unavailable in their
area.
Jeff Germann, 48, from Springfield, Mo., is
a visiting Santa to a local hospital and
private events.
Germann sees between 200 to 400 kids, or
more, each holiday season.
One of his charity events, called 'Breakfast
with Santa" at a hospital cafe, was
cancelled this year as a precautionary
measure due to swine flu concerns. "It was
my favorite thing to do," he said.
Still, that hasn't convinced him to get the
vaccination although he did get his regular
seasonal flu shot. "Personally, I'm afraid
to get it," he said. "I hear stories about
people who are getting sick from the shot."
Instead, Germann is taking other precautions
similar to what several malls and Santa
training schools are putting in place this
year.
For instance, one of the big Santa vendors
to malls is asking all its Santas to not
wear white gloves. Trolli said the reasoning
behind that is that it makes it easier for
Santas to apply hand sanitizer.
Malls are requiring hand sanitizing stations
wherever Santa sets up shop and that Santas
dryclean their suits frequently. Connaghan
also said parents should not bring their
children to meet Santa if they are sick.
"We want to protect the children," said
Trolli.
Despite the swine flu concerns, Trolli said
"Santa will still be Santa this year, and
bring a little bit of love and joy to
children."
First Published: December 4, 2009: 7:45
AM ET